Blog

March 18, 2015: CBA Professional Development Workshops in Washington, DC

by , January 26, 2015

The Society for Benefit-Cost Analysis (SBCA) will offer a series of six professional development workshops on March 18, 2015, prior to its 2015 Annual Conference and Meeting. The following workshops are organized by leading practitioners and scholars, and will take place at the Marvin Center at the George Washington University in Washington, D.C.

Continue

Using CBA to look beyond taxpayer savings

by , January 22, 2015

A fiscal note is an official estimate of a bill’s budgetary effects; such notes often accompany criminal justice policy proposals—a full 37 states produced at least one fiscal note concerning significant justice legislation from 2009 to 2011. (By comparison, 18 states conducted at least one criminal justice CBA during the same period.)

Rigorous and consistent fiscal notes allow policymakers to determine whether a bill will cost money, or save money, in the long term.

Continue

March 19-20, 2015: SBCA annual conference

by , January 12, 2015

The Society for Benefit-Cost Analysis (SBCA) has published a preliminary program for its seventh annual conference and meeting to be held on March 19 and 20 at the George Washington University Marvin Center in Washington, D.C.

The focus of this year’s conference is “Advancing the Policy Frontier.” The conference includes several panels at the intersection of economic analysis, criminal justice, and evidence-based decision making:

March 19

  • At 9 a.m., Stuart Shapiro, of Rutgers University, will chair the panel on social policy BCA, which includes two presentations on criminal justice.

Continue

CBKB 2014 Round-up

by , December 30, 2014

Beginning this week I’ll be posting regular updates to the blog. As Vera’s RBF Fellow, I will be here for only a year, but I have a lot planned for CBKB. In the coming year there will be a particular focus on the intersection of CBA and policymaking, including the emergence of Social Impact Bonds and the use of justice CBA outside the United States.

Continue

New CBKB publication outlines tools for conducting CBA for justice policy

by , December 23, 2014

As part of CBKB’s ongoing efforts to broaden and deepen the understanding and use of cost-benefit analysis (CBA) in criminal justice, this month we published the Cost-Benefit Analysis and Justice Policy Toolkit, which provides a step-by-step CBA guide and features several examples from the criminal justice field.

Cost-benefit analysis can be applied to a broad range of justice issues and help policymakers answer difficult questions, but there is no one-size-fits-all template for CBA; each analysis must be tailored to the investment being studied.

Continue

New CBKB publication focuses on public-safety technology and cost-benefit analysis

by , October 22, 2014

Criminal justice agencies often seek technological solutions to address safety issues and improve efficiency. What is the best way to inform public safety technology (PST) investments? Is cost-benefit analysis (CBA) a useful tool? The Vera Institute of Justice’s Cost-Benefit Knowledge Bank for Criminal Justice (CBKB) brought together a group of policymakers and practitioners to discuss the role of CBA in decisions about PSTs.

Continue

Oct. 17, 2014: Presentation proposals due for 2015 Society Benefit-Cost Analysis conference

by , August 14, 2014

The Society for Benefit-Cost Analysis (SBCA) is accepting papers for its 2015 annual conference, “Advancing the Policy Frontier.”

Proposals are due Friday, October 17, 2014. Submissions may address the link between theory and practice, the methods used to estimate particular types of costs or benefits, the application of BCA to specific case studies, and the role of BCA in decision making.

Continue

New Report Examines Each State’s Correctional Health Care Spending

Nationwide, state correctional health care spending totaled $7.7 billion in 2011—an amount that comprises 20 percent of overall prison expenditures, according to a new report from the State Health Care Spending Project, an initiative of The Pew Charitable Trusts and the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation. Inmate health care costs make up a larger share of state prison budgets than in 2001, but these expenses have leveled off since 2009, a trend that aligns with the recent nationwide deceleration of health care spending.

Continue

CBKB Round-up: Cost-benefit analysis and law enforcement

by , July 1, 2014

Cost-benefit analysis is increasingly being used to study law enforcement. The Washington State Institute of Public Policy, for instance, now calculates the return on investment of deploying an additional police officer as part of its “Consumer Reports-like list” of policy options. Previous CBKB blog posts have explored several issues and concerns related to the costs and benefits of policing.

Continue

The CBKB webinar archive: something for everyone

by , June 18, 2014

CBKB is not only a clearinghouse for written materials. Since 2010, we have presented 10 webinars—many co-presented with researchers and practitioners in the field—as part of our work to broaden and deepen the use of cost-benefit analysis for justice policymaking.

Six of these webinars are targeted to the analysts who prepare CBAs.

Continue

How to answer the question “Is this cost-benefit analysis baloney?”

A few years ago, a colleague asked me a pointed question about cost-benefit analysis: “Is it useful or a bunch of baloney?” (Actually, her words were a bit saltier.) We had worked together at the New York City Office of Management and Budget—and budget offices incubate a healthy dose of skepticism.

Continue

April 30, 2014: Cost-benefit analysis on agenda of Smart Policing Initiative conference

by , April 25, 2014

Tina Chiu, director of technical assistance at the Vera Institute of Justice, will be in Alexandria, Virginia, on Wednesday, April 30, to talk about cost-benefit analysis and Vera’s technical assistance resources at the spring national meeting of the Smart Policing Initiative (SPI).

Law enforcement and research teams from the following cities will participate in the three-day conference: Chula Vista, California; East Palo Alto, California; Port St.

Continue

Recent additions to the CBKB reference database

by , April 24, 2014

The CBKB reference database has more than 500 cost-benefit studies, articles, and papers that evaluate a variety of justice functions, initiatives, and programs. We recently added these six cost-benefit analyses (CBAs).

CBAs of correctional programs
Elizabeth Drake. Inventory of Evidence-Based and Research-Based Programs for Adult Corrections. Olympia, WA: Washington State Institute of Public Policy, 2013, http://www.wsipp.wa.gov/ReportFile/1542/Wsipp_Inventory-of-Evidence-Based-and-Research-Based-Programs-for-Adult-Corrections_Final-Report.pdf (accessed ‎December ‎13, ‎2013).

Continue

New from CBKB: “Using Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policymaking”

by , April 10, 2014

Any number of investments can promote public safety, whether in law enforcement, corrections, community corrections—or even programs such as early childhood education. The critical question, though, is which choices produce the greatest benefits.

Increasingly, decision makers are turning to cost-benefit analysis (CBA) to help weigh their options. But justice-related cost-benefit studies can be complicated, technical, and hard to understand, making it easy for people to misinterpret their findings and overlook critical information that can aid their decisions.

Continue

Police legitimacy: Resources and a NIJ seminar on April 21 in DC

by , April 9, 2014

As part of its Research for the Real World seminar series, the National Institute of Justice will host the event “Building Trust Inside and Out: The Challenge of Legitimacy Facing Police Leaders,” featuring Professor Dennis Rosenbaum, director of the Center for Research in Law and Justice at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

Continue

Know your costs: An example from the UK

by , April 7, 2014

The nongovernmental organization New Economy, in partnership with the UK government, recently released a database of more than 600 cost estimates. This unit cost database—available at the Centre for Social Impact Bonds—covers crime, education and skills, employment and economy, fire, health, housing, and social services. Most are national costs derived from government reports and academic studies.

Continue

The value of crime analysts: Part 2 of a Q&A with BJA visiting fellow Craig Uchida

by , April 3, 2014

Dr. Craig D. Uchida is the president of Justice & Security Strategies, Inc., where he oversees contracts and grants with cities, counties, criminal justice agencies, foundations, and foreign nations. He is also a member of the Law Enforcement Forecasting Group (LEFG), a program of the Bureau of Justice Assistance (BJA.) Last year, LEFG asked Vera’s Cost-Benefit Knowledge Bank to develop the paper Putting a Value on Crime Analysts: Considerations for Law Enforcement Executives.

Continue

The value of crime analysts: Part 1 of a Q&A with BJA visiting fellow Craig Uchida

by , April 1, 2014

140326 UchidaDr. Craig D. Uchida is the president of Justice & Security Strategies, Inc., where he oversees contracts and grants with cities, counties, criminal justice agencies, foundations, and foreign nations. He is also a member of the Law Enforcement Forecasting Group (LEFG), a program of the Bureau of Justice Assistance (BJA). Last year, LEFG asked CBKB to develop the paper Putting a Value on Crime Analysts: Considerations for Law Enforcement Executives.

Continue

New resources on drug courts and cost-efficiency analysis

by , March 31, 2014

The Adult Drug Court Research-to-Practice Initiative (R2P)—a project of the National Center for State Courts (NCSC) and the Justice Programs Office of the School of Public Affairs at American University—recently conducted the webinar “Drug Court Cost-Efficiency Analysis: Methods and Findings.”

The online panel discussion, moderated by Fred L. Cheesman II, principal court research consultant at NCSC, covers how to conduct drug court cost-efficiency analysis—including guidance on marginal costs, transactional costs, and monetizing drug-court outcomes—as well as what the current cost-effectiveness research tells us about adult drug courts.

Continue

New from CBKB, “Putting a Value on Crime Analysts: Considerations for Law Enforcement Executives”

by , March 27, 2014

Like other government agencies, police departments are under great pressure to get the biggest return possible when investing taxpayers’ dollars on justice programs and policies. Leaders of the Law Enforcement Forecasting Group of the U.S. Department of Justice’s Bureau of Justice Assistance asked staff from CBKB to develop this document, to help police departments address questions about spending on crime analysts—and about justifying that spending.

Continue